Thomas jefferson and benjamin banneker primary source. Tell students they will read excerpts from this letter and identify the ways in which banneker developed his argument and challenged jefferson to live up to his stated beliefs. Benjamin banneker, the negro mathematician and astronomer. From thomas jefferson to benjamin bannekerfrom thomas jefferson to benjamin bannekerfrom thomas jefferson to benjamin banneker philadelphia, august 30, 1791. Rhetorical device benjamin banneker letter to thomas. The letter from banneker to jefferson incorporates very welleducated and formal diction in his argument against the issue of slavery. In this lesson students will read letters written by benjamin banneker, a black freeman, and thomas jefferson. Jefferson then attempted to combine his first argument, that the servitude of an. Rhetorical analysis on benjamin bannekers letter to thomas. Born in baltimore county, maryland, to a free africanamerican woman and a former slave, banneker.
In his letter to thomas jefferson and george washington in. Banneker, a free africanamerican astronomer, mathematician, scientist and writer, published his letter and jefferson. Dec 15, 2014 benjamin banneker, in his letter to thomas jefferson in 1791, argues for an end to the injustice and inequality that was slavery. Less than two weeks after benjamin banneker wrote to thomas jefferson, challenging the democratic ideology that denied liberty and humanity to blacks, jefferson sent him a polite response dated. A rhetorical analysis of benjamin bannekers letter to thomas. Banneker s use of this strategy was even more effective, given the fact that thomas jefferson himself was one of the founding fathers who signed the declaration of independence. Fordham speaks on the debate that pioneering black scientist benjamin bannker had against future president thomas jefferson on race and intelligence in. Benjamin banneker wrote this letter to attempt to make the secretary of state, thomas jefferson, aware of the oppressive and horrifying nature of the slave trade that banneker s ancestors had been in for generations.
Benjamin bannekers inscribed equilateral triangle introduction. Born in baltimore county, maryland, to a free africanamerican woman and a former slave, banneker had little formal education and was largely selftaught. Banneker, benjamin and jefferson, thomasexcerpt from a letter to thomas jefferson and jeffersons response written august 19 and august 30, 1791 available at university of virginia library web site source for information on banneker, benjamin and jefferson, thomas. Letter to thomas jefferson, transmitting a copy of the writers almanac and discussing the subject of slavery. Mss 1 banneker s letter, with this reply, was printed in pamphlet form, as follows copy of a letter from benjamin banneker to the secretary of state, with his answer. Benjamin banneker uses logos to establish his arguments.
Letter to thomas jefferson 1791 log in to see the full document and commentary. Aug 19, 20 however, it was bannekers challenge, by way of written correspondence, to thensecretary of state thomas jefferson on the act of slavery that would also add to his legacy. Banneker uses multiple rhetoric strategies in his letter. The national historical publications and records commission nhprc is part of the national archives. His use of pathos and logos as well as his allusions to the bible and the declaration of independence make for a very well structured letter that makes for a very clear and effective argument.
Included in the download are printable versions of the 2 letters. Banneker begins each paragraph with the greeting sir in respect to thomas jefferson. What was benjamin bannekers letter to thomas jefferson. Banneker rhetorical essay benjamin banneker, a son of former slaves and an educated scholar, wrote a letter to thomas jefferson arguing about the mistreatment of slaves and the injustice of slavery. Benjamin banneker essay matt gottstines ap lang portfolio. Title thomas jefferson to benjamin banneker, august 30, 1791 created published 17910830. Africans in americapart 2jeffersons reply to banneker. Benjamin banneker challenges thomas jeffersons support. Thomas jefferson, slavery, and slaves papers in the ssrn. On august 19, 1791, benjamin banneker wrote a lengthy letter to thomas jefferson, then secretary of state, in which having taken up my pen in order to direct to you as a present, a copy of an. Banneker s main purpose for writing this letter to thomas jefferson was to bring to light the adversity and trials of the slave community by juxtaposing the similar hardships faced by the audience he was attempting to appeal to, thomas jefferson.
Benjamin banneker wrote this letter to attempt to make the secretary of state, thomas jefferson, aware of the oppressive and horrifying nature of the slave trade that bannekers ancestors had been in for generations. Evans 24073 jefferson s reply, dated august 30, 1791. Benjamin banneker november 9, 1731 october 19, 1806 was a free africanamerican almanac author, surveyor, naturalist, and farmer. Students read and analyze excerpts from a letter from scientist benjamin banneker to thomas jefferson challenging jefferson s view of african americans. Later in the letter, banneker, in order to emphasize the sad irony of the situation. Thomas jefferson letter to benjamin banneker version the jefferson. No body wishes more than i do to see such proofs as you exhibit, that nature has given to. Benjamin banneker, a slave, farmer, astronomer, surveyor, and author, establishes ethos, pathos, and logos in his letter to thomas jefferson.
Benjamin banneker called out thomas jefferson us 101. Click here to request a free trial account only available to college instructors primary. Benjamin banneker debates thomas jefferson youtube. Banneker s letter to jefferson sir, i am fully sensible of the greatness of that freedom, which i take with you on the present occasion. Students were directed to write an essay that analyzes how banneker uses rhetorical. Dated august 30, 1791, secretary of state thomas jefferson penned this letter in response to benjamin banneker questioning his commitment to liberty.
Neden ap language 15 december 2014 benjamin banneker uses many rhetorical strategies in his letter to thomas jefferson and george washington to argue against slavery. Benjamin banneker, the negro mathematician and astronomer jstor. Benjamin bannekers accomplishments extended into other realms as well, including civil rights. Banneker expresses this by using the rhetorical strategies.
Thomas jefferson papers while serving as secretary of state, thomas jefferson 17431826, one of virginias largest planters and slaveholders, wrote this 30 august 1791 response to benjamin. Benjamin banneker 17311806 was an africanamerican mathematician, surveyor, astronomer, and publisher of a popular almanac. Letter from benjamin banneker to thomas jefferson benjamin banneker was way ahead of his time for african americans. Feb 06, 2018 benjamin banneker, an early africanamerican mathematician and scientist, wrote thomas jefferson and called him out on his stance on slavery. This letter was composed in order to exhibit banneker s view on the crying shame of slavery. Thomas jefferson, notes on the state of virginia 1784, 1787, reply to benjamin banneker august 30, 1791, letter to joel barlow 1809 emigration vs. Benjamin banneker is one of the greatest scientists in american history making it all the more unfortunate that, even in an era of increasing multicultural awareness, biographies of this brilliant. Benjamin banneker sends his almanac to thomas jefferson by jay. Copy of a letter from benjamin banneker to the secretary of state, with his answer. His purpose is to connect with thomas jefferson in order for him to take part in abolishing slavery. In 1791, benjamin banneker wrote a letter to thomas jefferson, who was then the secretary of state, making a forceful and powerful argument against slavery.
Students were directed to write an essay that analyzes how banneker. Aug 29, 2010 bannekers main purpose for writing this letter to thomas jefferson was to bring to light the adversity and trials of the slave community by juxtaposing the similar hardships faced by the audience he was attempting to appeal to, thomas jefferson, using. In 1791 benjamin banneker, the son of former slaves, astronomer, and almanac author, wrote a letter to thomas jefferson, in a courteous but forceful manner, challenging the framer of the declaration of independence and secretary of state on the topics of race and freedom. Benjamin bannekers inscribed equilateral triangle how to use.
Jan 30, 2020 benjamin banneker november 9, 1731october 9, 1806 was a selfeducated scientist, astronomer, inventor, writer, and antislavery publicist. Rhetorical analysis of banneker to jefferson research paper. Biography of benjamin banneker, author and naturalist. From thomas jefferson to benjamin banneker, 30 august 1791. He attended grammar school only briefly, but banneker s keen innate intelligence enabled him to teach. Banneker uses tone, ethos, logos, pathos, syntax, juxtaposition, and scheme to sympathize with jefferson. In 1791, thomas jefferson was secretary of state and banneker considered the respected virginian, though a slaveholder, to also be open to viewing african americans as more than slaves. Letter from thomas jefferson to benjamin banneker aug. To thomas jefferson from benjamin banneker, 19 august 1791 maryland. While banneker writes a letter to thomas jefferson to give his side of the argument towards slavery, he expresses his thought through repetition, appealing to emotion, blaming him for his actions, and a reference to the bible. In this letter, banneker pointed to the contradictions between the principles laid out in the declaration of independence and bill of rights, and the continued existence of slavery.
Benjamin bannekers letter to thomas jefferson rhetorical analysis in a letter to thomas jefferson an advocate for slavery and framer of the declaration of independence. Biography sir, suffer me to recal to your mind that time, in which the arms and tyranny of the british crown were exerted, with every powerful effort, in order to reduce you to a state. No body wishes more than i do, to see such proofs as you exhibit, that. Benjamin bannekers letter to thomas jefferson prezi. He apologised in his letter for approaching jefferson. Banneker, jefferson, and the declaration of independence purpose. American attitudes toward the negro, 15501812 chapel hill, n. He attended grammar school only briefly, but bannekers keen innate intelligence enabled him to teach.
In subsequent editions of almanacs banneker produced in later years, he opted to reprint his letter to jefferson. Banneker begins each paragraph with the greeting sir in respect to thomas jefferson, who is higher than. On august 19, 1791, black writer, scientist, and farmer, benjamin banneker, wrote a public letter to secretary of state thomas jefferson, challenging jefferson s proslavery views as inconsistent with the ideals of the declaration of independence. Banneker implies that the freedom of all men is, as jefferson himself declared in 1776, an inalienable right endowed by a merciful creator, and that jefferson, as a former sufferer under the tyranny of king george, should understand that concept better than most. For more information about banneker, including images of his almanac and of a letter to him from thomas jefferson, see the website, mathematicians of the. Letter, thomas jefferson to benjamin banneker expressing his belief that blacks possess talents equal to those of other colours of men, 30 august 1791. Rhetorical device benjamin banneker letter to thomas jefferson. Rhetorical annalysis of benjamin bannekers letter to thomas.
To thomas jefferson from benjamin banneker, 19 august 1791. Benjamin banneker benjamin banneker s letter to thomas jefferson implores him to. Benjamin bannekers letter to jefferson analysis by lamin. Benjamin bannekers letter to thomas jefferson, 1791. Banneker sent a first edition to thomas jefferson, then secretary of science in washingtons cabinet, in order to promote the intellectual ability of africanamericans. Ra of benjamin banneker letter by phoebe powell on prezi.
Benjamin banneker s letter to thomas jefferson, written in 1791 when jefferson was secretary of state, argues that jefferson should abandon his proslavery stance and support the abolition of slavery. Rhetorical annalysis of benjamin bannekers letter to. In benjamin banneker s letter to thomas jefferson he argues that he wants slavery to be discontinued. Benjamin banneker addresses thomas jefferson as sir throughout the letter in lines 1,15,18,26. Banneker wrote a nowfamous letter to thomas jefferson on august. After unveiling the contradiction within the constitution and the country itself, banneker appeals to religion to further weaken jefferson. Benjamin banneker addresses thomas jefferson as sir throughout the letter.
Tell students they will read excerpts from this letter and identify the ways in which banneker developed his argument and challenged jefferson. Benjamin banneker, a son of former slaves and an educated scholar, wrote a letter to thomas jefferson arguing about the mistreatment of slaves and the injustice. Sir, i thank you, sincerely, for your letter of the 19th instant, and for the almanac it contained. For two weeks, banneker labored over the letter, and on august 19, 1791 he read his handwritten letter for the last time and sealed it into a package with the manuscript, directing to thomas jefferson, secretary of state. Benjamin banneker, a son of former slaves and an educated scholar, wrote a letter to thomas jefferson arguing about the mistreatment of slaves and the injustice of slavery. Banneker, a free africanamerican astronomer, mathematician, scientist and writer, published his letter and jefferson s response in a 1793 almanac. Biography sir, suffer me to recal to your mind that time, in which the arms and tyranny of the british crown were exerted, with every powerful effort, in order to reduce you to a state of servitude. Benjamin banneker wrote this letter to attempt to make the secretary of state, thomas jefferson, aware of the oppressive and horrifying nature of the slave trade that banneker s ancestors had been in for.
Letter to benjamin banneker august 30, 1791 wikisource. Sir, i thank you sincerely for your letter of the 19th instant and for the almanac it contained. This activity includes 2 primary source letters that thomas jefferson and benjamin banneker exchanged regarding slavery and human equality. Benjamin banneker rhetorical analysis essay sample astronomer, mathematician, and writer benjamin banneker penned a powerful letter to thomas jefferson in 1791, asking him to end the injustice of slavery in postcolonial america.
Rhetorical analysis on benjamin bannekers letter to. This letter was composed in order to exhibit bannekers view on the crying shame of slavery. Founded in 1900, the college board is composed of more than 5,700 schools, colleges, universities and other. He touches on the topics of the way blacks were treated and seen by the. Africans in americapart 2bannekers letter to jefferson pbs. In 1791 benjamin banneker, the son of former slaves, astronomer, and almanac author, wrote a letter to thomas jefferson, in a courteous but forceful manner, challenging the framer of the declaration of. Ap english language and composition 2010 freeresponse questions. On august 19, 1791, benjamin banneker wrote a lengthy letter to thomas jefferson, then secretary of state, in which having taken up my pen in order to direct.
Jefferson papers title from thomas jefferson to benjamin banneker, 30 august 1791 author jefferson, thomas recipient banneker, benjamin date 30 august 1791 reference cite as from thomas jefferson to benjamin banneker. He assumes a knowledgeable and matterof fact persona in order to challenge jeffersons loya. Rhetorical devices, figurative language and effects in. Thomas jefferson to benjamin banneker, august 30, 1791. Letter from benjamin banneker to thomas jefferson 1791. Ap english language and composition 2010 freeresponse. Africans in americapart 2bannekers letter to jefferson. Benjamin banneker sends his almanac to thomas jefferson. Benjamin banneker white house historical association. That same year, a free africanamerican, benjamin banneker, challenged the way blacks were seen and treated by whites in america in a public letter to thomas jefferson. Shaping of america, 17831815 reference library dictionary. Banneker s accomplishments and the wellknown exchange of letters between banneker and tj are described in silvio a. Mar 05, 2016 author, historian, and lecturer damon l.
Benjamin banneker uses logos to establish his arguments kibin. Copy of a letter from benjamin banneker to the secretary. Through its grants program, the nhprc supports a wide range of activities to preserve, publish, and encourage the use of documentary sources, relating to the history of the united states, and research and development projects to bring historical records to the public. Benjamin bannekers almanacs and letters illustrate african americans quest to eradicate slavery and racial discrimination. He built a striking clock entirely from wood, published a farmers almanac, and actively campaigned against slavery.
Students will write letters on the subject in their own words. Bedini, the life of benjamin banneker new york, 1972. Benjamin bannekers 1791 letter to thomas jefferson. Ap english language and composition 2010 freeresponse questions the college board the college board is a notforprofit membership association whose mission is to connect students to college success and opportunity. In his letter to thomas jefferson and george washington in 1791, he was able to strongly advocate against the institution of slavery and the oppression of all black peoples in america. Copy of a letter from benjamin banneker to the secretary of state. Nguyen 1 anhthu nguyen period 4 language arts 92917 mrs. He attended grammar school only briefly, but banneker.
211 654 1078 636 1045 975 268 593 591 1601 531 1384 1480 279 437 815 621 789 792 1375 1091 626 232 308 1392 23 394 723 262 419 36 1471 1428 1160